社区黑料

Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for 社区黑料 Newsletter

Already at odds over Israel鈥檚 war in Gaza, the National Education Association is divided again this summer over a highly contested attempt to prohibit all engagement with the Anti-Defamation League, a prominent nonprofit dedicated to fighting antisemitism. 

Delegates to the organization鈥檚 representative assembly last month narrowly voted to created by the Jewish advocacy group. They also the union from participating in programs led by the ADL or publicizing its professional development opportunities. But the NEA鈥檚 executive commission rejected the proposal days later following . 

The episode reopened an ongoing clash among the 3 million school employees represented by the union 鈥� the largest in the country by far 鈥� over numerous armed conflicts in the Middle East, alleged prejudice against both Jews and Arabs at home and how schools should teach about both. 

Teachers鈥� unions related to Israel, a trend that escalated rapidly in the wake of Hamas鈥� attack on the country Oct. 7, 2023, and the war that followed. But with the Trump administration in education, the about-face from the NEA suggests that the issue is increasingly viewed as treacherous ground. An ongoing Republican attempt to terminate the union鈥檚 congressional charter may be adding still more pressure. 

While noting that their decision to scuttle the measure was 鈥渋n no way an endorsement of the ADL鈥檚 full body of work,鈥� the union鈥檚 leadership expressed concerns over rising antisemitism, pledging to carefully review curricula designed to combat it. 

鈥淎fter consideration, it was determined that this proposal would not further NEA鈥檚 commitment to academic freedom, our membership or our goals,鈥� the authors concluded.

The delegates鈥� original motion to disaffiliate came after a series of confrontations with the ADL, which has been vocal in attacking what it deems as hateful and biased content circulated by educators. Throughout 2024 and 2025, the ADL has issued report cards for colleges and universities, accusing them of ignoring antisemitism during student protests against Israel鈥檚 wars in Gaza, Lebanon and Iran; their critical grades by members of Congress seeking to pressure the institutions into taking more dramatic action against student activists.

The disputes have extended into K鈥�12 schools as well, with the Massachusetts Teachers Association (an NEA affiliate) for circulating teaching materials it called antisemitic, including images of a dollar bill folded into a Star of David. For their part, the that the materials were mischaracterized and that the ADL鈥檚 denunciations had triggered death threats to MTA leaders and staff.

Merrie Najimy, a former president of the Massachusetts union who supported the anti-ADL resolution, said in an email that the since-reversed vote at the representative assembly 鈥渟ignals a sea change in the desire of the NEA rank-and-file for a new position from both their union and politicians.鈥�

鈥淭he ADL consistently commits acts of anti-Palestinian racism by falsely conflating the criticism of Zionism and Israel with antisemitism, dehumanizing the Palestinian People [sic], pushing to erase and censor Palestinian narratives in schools and targeting educators who speak up for Palestinian rights,鈥� Najimy wrote. 

Growing divisions

Patrick Crabtree, a retired teacher who served for four years as chair of the NEA Jewish Affairs Caucus, said he was deeply concerned that his fellow members had taken sides against 鈥渙ne of the most reputable organizations in America.鈥� 

鈥淚t shocked me that it was even under consideration,鈥� he said. 鈥淎nd it shocked me even more that it passed.鈥�

I've heard it said more than once, 鈥榃e're not the National Everything Association.鈥� When we become so political, I think it turns a lot of people off who are more concerned with whether they鈥檙e going to keep their jobs.

Patrick Crabtree, former NEA Jewish Affairs Caucus chair and retired teacher

Crabtree observed that harsh sentiments against Israel have been somewhat commonplace during his involvement with the union. Delegates to officially declare support for Palestinians after a spasm of violence in 2021, when the Israeli Defense Forces and Hamas traded airstrikes and missile volleys that killed hundreds. Once the IDF launched its invasion of Gaza, activists within the union to revoke its 2024 endorsement for Joe Biden, arguing that the president hadn鈥檛 done enough to restrain Israel. 

Dissension has spread to other teachers unions as well. In May, Michael Mulgrew encountered unusual resistance in winning a sixth term as president of New York City鈥檚 United Federation of Teachers. Accustomed to breezy victories, Mulgrew faced two challengers advocating for a more militant stance against Israel, including from any enterprises in the country. The combined share of the opposing candidacies of the union鈥檚 vote, indicating high levels of support for such policies. 

A few weeks later, the UFT New York City mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani, who has been bluntly critical of Israel鈥檚 actions in Gaza. 

Jerald Podair, a historian at Wisconsin鈥檚 Lawrence University, wrote about a seminal collision of American education politics: the 1968 teachers strike, when the UFT led a lengthy work stoppage after a number of Brooklyn teachers claimed that they had been subjected to antisemitic discrimination by the local Ocean Hill-Brownsville school board. 

At that time, the union鈥檚 membership was predominantly Jewish, including a large number of Holocaust survivors. In the decades since, he reflected, the UFT has become both more willing to wade into national politics and more internally divided on what positions to adopt.

鈥淎t Ocean Hill-Brownsville, the UFT was composed of moderately liberal members, virtually all of whom supported Israel,鈥� Podair said. 鈥淪o I think it’s fair to say that there is less homogeneity today 鈥� certainly less ethnic homogeneity 鈥� and less unanimity about the issues they choose to interject on.”

Politics as 鈥榮ideshow鈥�

Divisions within the NEA have become even more sharply defined since its executive commission, led by President Becky Pringle, dismissed the measure targeting the ADL.

Najimy called the move 鈥渁 fundamental violation of union democracy [that] has caused great harm to the Jewish and Arab-American educators who crafted and fought for it.鈥�

鈥淲hat鈥檚 more important,鈥� she continued, 鈥渋s that the education about the ADL went far beyond the walls of the representative assembly, and the desire of the representative assembly cannot be undone.鈥�

With tensions around antisemitism rising to a level rarely seen in recent U.S. history, education leaders around the country are taking steps to distance themselves and their institutions from perceptions of animus toward Jews. In response to threats from the Trump administration to remove billions of dollars in funding over violations of federal antidiscrimination statutes, Harvard to identify and remedy instances of antisemitism. Columbia, while not admitting any wrongdoing, agreed to pay $221 million into similar allegations. 

Even before President Donald Trump took office, both colleges following congressional hearings into antisemitism on their campuses. The Biden administration the School District of Philadelphia for taking insufficient steps to counter discrimination during the 2022鈥�23 and 2023鈥�24 school years.

Official sanctions have also been considered in the case of the NEA, with Republicans in Washington introducing legislation of its congressional charter. Sponsors specifically pointed to last month鈥檚 vote to break with the ADL as an impetus for the bill, though the GOP has weighed similar proposals in years past. (The consequences of losing the charter would be more symbolic than practical, though conservative activists for the more drastic step of barring the NEA from political organizing.)

Podair said Pringle鈥檚 intervention in the ADL spat likely reflected a belief that engagement in the hottest of political imbroglios didn鈥檛 offer sufficient upside in the fight that matters most to her supporters.

“The politics, for most union members, is a sideshow,鈥� he said. 鈥淲hat really matters is how much money you make and what your health plan looks like. If you don’t deliver for your members on those things, you can take all the political stances you want, but you’re still going to be out.”

Crabtree shared the same view, adding that his own conversations with fellow union members usually revolved around pay and working conditions, with some concerns around explicitly education-related policies like school choice programs. Lately, he鈥檇 been hearing a familiar quip.

Did you use this article in your work?

We鈥檇 love to hear how 社区黑料鈥檚 reporting is helping educators, researchers, and policymakers.