社区黑料

Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for 社区黑料 Newsletter

America鈥檚 schools are crumbling.

There鈥檚 black mold in buildings in and . Classrooms in and lack proper heating and cooling. And there are persistent plumbing problems in and .

America鈥檚 aging school infrastructure is by one measure a nearly $90 billion problem. Federal leaders have acknowledged it but have declined to address it. Local school districts and state governments also haven鈥檛 solved it 鈥� in some cases, even after being ordered by a court to do so.

It鈥檚 a problem so big that one congressional candidate running to represent parts of Philadelphia 鈥� where the cost of repairing and upgrading public schools could cost up to 鈥� is making it the centerpiece of his campaign. After struggling to find solutions in the Pennsylvania Legislature, state Sen. Sharif Street, a Democrat, believes only the federal government has the resources to tackle this issue. He thinks a $500 billion block grant proposal could find bipartisan support in a Congress and a country deeply divided on the federal government鈥檚 role in education.

鈥淚f we don鈥檛 address this at a federal level and come up with a massive amount of money to do so, we鈥檙e going to constantly be in a space of choosing all bad options,鈥� Street said.

Those who lobby for the issue say Street鈥檚 proposal could put thousands of people to work, boost test scores, and strengthen communities. Street thinks it could 鈥� and must 鈥� be .

To make his case in Congress, Street must first get through a for the 3rd Congressional District on May 19. The winner of the primary is the heavy favorite to win the November election.

Regardless of whether Street wins the seat, advocates say it鈥檚 rare for a congressional candidate to make school infrastructure a key issue in a pitch to voters.

鈥淚t is absolutely viable, if Congress has the will to do it, and it would be transformative for America鈥檚 families and communities for decades to come,鈥� said Ally Talcott, executive director of the Build America鈥檚 School Infrastructure Coalition, of Street鈥檚 proposal. 鈥淚 think it is quite possibly one of the areas that could bring the country together.鈥�

But Street is where others have . Convincing conservatives to support sending $500 billion for school facilities through a Department of Education the Trump administration is working to dismantle would be a tough sell, even if local bond measures for school infrastructure continue to do well at the ballot box.

R. Richard Geddes, a nonresident senior fellow at the conservative American Enterprise Institute specializing in infrastructure policy, said he thinks school construction and maintenance is 鈥渁 huge sleeper issue鈥� that few are paying close attention to.

Still, for a proposal like Street鈥檚 to succeed and that money be spent efficiently, Geddes there should be conditions. He suggested requiring municipalities to to build 550 bridges, or setting up a federal credit program like .

Asking thousands of local education agencies to apply for some of the $500 billion pot would be 鈥渁 mess,鈥� and those districts wouldn鈥檛 reap the benefits of scale, Geddes said.

Cities and municipalities should also consider public-private partnerships, Geddes said. That could look like attaching a privately owned gym or coffee shop to a school building to generate revenue that could pay for a portion of the building maintenance.

Geddes said that could come with its own controversy, but 鈥渋t would still be better than what we have, which is a lack of creative thinking.鈥�

State and local funding lags for school infrastructure

To accommodate the baby boom generation, cities and towns built thousands of new schools. Since then, the fertility rate has declined, and post-pandemic . That鈥檚 left many school buildings half empty and costly to maintain.

State and local lawmakers typically patch up the worst infrastructure issues with small-dollar grants and emergency funds. But they their school facilities鈥� needs. As of 2023, 13 states contributed less than 10% toward local district investments in school construction and capital improvements, according to the 21st Century School Fund鈥檚 from last year. And 10 states made no contributions at all.

It鈥檚 estimated that the average annual gap between what districts are spending on their public school facilities and what is needed is nearly $90 billion nationally, according to the State of the Schools report.

It鈥檚 a crucial education issue that has been politically 鈥渙rphaned,鈥� despite recent history indicating it can be relatively popular with voters said Mary Filardo, a school construction finance expert and founder of the 21st Century School Fund. Voters approved in 2025, and they approved nearly 74% in 2024.

In May, Texas voters approved a $6.2 billion school bond 鈥� .

But local funding hasn鈥檛 been sufficient to meet all the needs. And in some places, like Philly, the school district lacks taxing authority altogether.

In Street鈥檚 hometown of Philadelphia, the school facilities crisis has become one of the most pressing political issues in the city. With a $300 million budget deficit and declining student population, the district is moving forward with a $3 billion plan to close 17 schools and modernize nearly 170 others.

. The district鈥檚 annual budget is $4.5 billion, yet estimates for the total cost to repair and upgrade its schools range from to nearly .

鈥淧hiladelphia is one of the great American cities. And it鈥檚 like, how did you let this get this bad?鈥� said Filardo.

Pennsylvania鈥檚 previous program to fund school repairs, known as PlanCon, . A new version has never received state funding.

鈥淭here鈥檚 no way that the city or the state at the local level can actually fully address those needs,鈥� Street said. 鈥淲e just can鈥檛 do it.鈥�

Street said his proposal, which he acknowledged is a starting point and could end up being much smaller than $500 billion, would have the Department of Education send out funding through an as-yet-undeveloped formula that factors in local population and needs.

The Philadelphia school district spends about $770 million on facilities a year, mostly on debt service and emergency repairs when roofs collapse or boilers fail, Filardo said. Those emergency repairs can end up costing more than regular maintenance and upkeep.

Filardo says for districts like Philly it鈥檚 a bit of a paradox: 鈥淭hey鈥檙e not spending enough, but they鈥檙e spending a lot, and they鈥檙e not getting as good a value from what they are spending.鈥�

Geddes said when cities and towns are faced with budget crises, 鈥渢he easiest thing to do in the world is defer maintenance.鈥� That goes for roads, sidewalks, and electrical grids as well as schools.

He suggested one condition of receiving federal funding could be locking in contracts that would commit municipalities to funding 10 or 12 years of proper maintenance in advance.

That maintenance will be critical, Filardo warned, as and the batter buildings and put extra pressure on electrical systems.

School infrastructure funded with 鈥榟odgepodge鈥� of federal policies

Talcott of the infrastructure coalition said the way the country currently treats school construction funding is via 鈥渁 hodgepodge of federal policies.鈥� Funding goes out piecemeal through several agencies and departments including the Federal Emergency Management Agency, the Department of Education, and the Department of Energy.

A bill in Congress aims to take on the problem, but it鈥檚 a far cry from the $500 billion Street is seeking.

The co-sponsored by U.S. Sen. Jack Reed, a Rhode Island Democrat, and U.S. Rep. Bobby Scott, a Virginia Democrat, would set aside $100 billion in direct grants and $30 billion in bonding authority over five years for school construction.

But Scott, the ranking member on the House Committee on Education and the Workforce, said gaining support for the legislation has felt like an uphill battle. The bill currently has no Republican cosponsors and hasn鈥檛 had a hearing. Scott and other lawmakers have introduced a version of the bill four times since 2019.

鈥淚f the locality can鈥檛 afford it and the state鈥檚 not doing it, then it鈥檚 either going to be the federal government or it won鈥檛 get done,鈥� Scott said.

Chalkbeat is a nonprofit news site covering educational change in public schools. This story was originally published by Chalkbeat. Sign up for their newsletters at .

Did you use this article in your work?

We鈥檇 love to hear how 社区黑料鈥檚 reporting is helping educators, researchers, and policymakers.