社区黑料

Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for 社区黑料 Newsletter

Sign up for to keep up with NYC鈥檚 public schools.

Sweeping changes to literacy instruction are underway in New York City, with all elementary schools for the first time using this September.

By requiring instruction in line with long-standing research about how children learn to read, known as the , the city is hoping to boost its literacy rates. Just under half of students in grades 3-8 , according to state exams.

After Chancellor David Banks took the helm of the nation鈥檚 school district more than two years ago, he said the city鈥檚 approach to reading instruction and has since made the curriculum overhaul his signature initiative. His other policies, , pale in comparison to fixing reading instruction.

鈥淣one of that will even matter if kids can鈥檛 read,鈥� he said.

But what do the new curriculums look like? How do caregivers know if they鈥檙e working? And what should you do if your child continues to struggle?

Here are answers to some common questions caregivers may have about the changes, based on interviews with reading experts and educators.

How were schools teaching reading before?

Stretching back decades, the Education Department developed by Teachers College professor Lucy Calkins, which viewed reading as a natural process that could be unlocked by exposing students to literature. Teachers delivered mini-lessons on a specific skill then encouraged students to read books at their individual levels to practice what they learned.

But most reading experts say the approach did not include enough emphasis on teaching children the relationships between letters and sounds, known as phonics, leaving behind a substantial share of students who would benefit from more explicit sound-it-out lessons.

Calkins鈥� curriculum also , such as encouraging students to use pictures to guess at a word鈥檚 meaning rather than relying on the letters themselves. Though she has since on phonics, the city鈥檚 public schools will no longer be allowed to use her program.

What is the philosophy behind the literacy shift?

All schools are now required to deliver regular phonics instruction that explicitly teaches the relationship between sounds and letters. Those lessons, which are prioritized , typically run about 30 minutes a day.

In addition to those lessons, schools must also use one of three approved reading programs that are designed to help build vocabulary and comprehension by exposing students to social studies and science topics alongside works of literature and poetry. that students are more likely to understand what they鈥檙e reading if they鈥檙e already familiar with the underlying topic. The new curriculums are designed to build students鈥� background knowledge across a range of domains.

鈥淵ou should, as a parent, ask your kid about the books that they鈥檙e reading and be prepared to hear an earful from your child about how they read about Jacques Cousteau and the discovery of the giant squid 鈥� or to know a whole lot about pollinators,鈥� said Kristen McQuillan, who consults with districts on literacy efforts and is affiliated with the Knowledge Matters Campaign, which raises awareness about the role of background knowledge in reading comprehension. Students should be bringing home writing about those books, too, she added.

Under the old curriculums, students often picked books that interested them from the classroom library that were targeted at their individual reading levels. Although the city is moving away from that leveling system 鈥� and instead having kids spend more time reading common books as a class 鈥� the practice may continue to some degree. Teachers will still have access to those leveled books, though they have been asked to organize them by topic or genre. Into Reading, the most widespread curriculum under the new mandate, also offers its own set of leveled books that schools can use.

What are the three new curriculums and which one is my school using?

The curriculum rollout began during the 2023-24 school year with 15 of the city鈥檚 32 local school districts required to use one of the three reading programs: Into Reading from the company Houghton Mifflin Harcourt; Wit and Wisdom from Great Minds; and EL Education from Imagine Learning.

Beginning this September, all elementary schools must use one of those three programs, with local superintendents in charge of making curriculum decisions for all schools in their district. Here鈥檚 what each district is using:

What do the three new reading curriculums look like?

Into Reading from Houghton Mifflin Harcourt

Into Reading is . Schools in 22 of New York City鈥檚 32 local districts must use it. The most traditional of the three curriculums, Into Reading is organized as an anthology-style textbook packed with passages specifically designed to help teach reading skills, an approach known in education jargon as a 鈥渂asal reader.鈥� Some caregivers may be familiar with the approach from .

Unlike the other two curriculums, Into Reading includes a Spanish-language version. And it covers a lot of ground, with roughly that include how plants live and grow, the relationship between sports and teamwork, and how a person鈥檚 experiences shape their identity. Some educators say that breadth can be helpful since students may be more likely to encounter subjects that pique their curiosity.

Kate Gutwillig, a veteran New York City educator who has taught all three of the mandated curriculums, recalled one instance where a fifth grader who was reading at a second-grade level was captivated by an Into Reading lesson on Greek mythology.

鈥淗e was able to read the Medusa myth and that kid just came to life 鈥� he wanted to read aloud and write,鈥� she said. 鈥淭here鈥檚 something good about having a lot of variety.鈥�

Still, Into Reading has earned criticism from some observers, parents, and educators who contend that it is weaker than the other two curriculums because it , and relies too heavily . A New York University report also warned that its materials are not culturally responsive, a claim the company .

Wit & Wisdom from Great Minds

Wit & Wisdom is known for building students鈥� background knowledge by going deeper into a smaller number of units. The curriculum includes 鈥� ranging from civil rights heroes to a study of outer space 鈥� devoting about 6-8 weeks per topic.

The curriculum exposes students to a mix of fiction and nonfiction texts. It also stands apart for including a 鈥渃lose examination of artwork related to the core topics,鈥� .

鈥淵ou tend to see a bit more of that literary fiction,鈥� said McQuillan. One fourth grade unit called 鈥渢he great heart鈥� introduces students to the biology of the heart as muscle that pumps blood while weaving in the figurative meaning of the heart as a representation of emotion and love.

Some educators say adapting to Wit & Wisdom is challenging. The lessons can be lengthy, requiring teachers to figure out how to cut it down to be more manageable. And, as with all three curriculums, students are generally expected to read the same books on their grade level as a class, a challenge for students who don鈥檛 yet have strong reading skills.

鈥淚 think that鈥檚 our biggest struggle,鈥� one teacher who was implementing Wit & Wisdom previously told Chalkbeat. 鈥淲e鈥檙e coming in assuming that the kids have the skills to do this.鈥� (If you鈥檙e interested in a deeper look at Wit & Wisdom, .)

EL Education from Imagine Learning

Similar to Wit & Wisdom, EL Education deploys a handful of units each year that students spend several weeks unpacking. Formerly called Expeditionary Learning, the curriculum and includes lots of opportunities to write. Two kindergarten units , for instance, and a significant chunk of second grade is devoted to pollination.

The emphasis on exploring the outside world, McQuillan said, 鈥渢ends to be a feature of EL that kids get excited about.鈥�

Janina Jarnich, who teaches second grade at P.S. 169 Baychester Academy in the Bronx, that one of her favorite lessons to teach focuses on paleontology and fossilization.

鈥淏y the end of the module, they write a narrative where they are the paleontologist that makes the greatest discovery of their lives,鈥� she said. The lesson 鈥渓ends itself to lots of hands-on experiences, like making imprints and doing a 鈥榙inosaur dig.鈥欌�� She also takes her students on a field trip to the Museum of Natural History.

Some educators noted that the curriculum can be overwhelming 鈥� an issue that some teachers said is true of many curriculum packages.

鈥淭he weakness is the difficulty of navigating all of the materials,鈥� Jarnich said. 鈥淓ven after using EL for four years, it can still be tricky to find the end-of-unit assessments and to make sure you have all of the materials necessary for each lesson.鈥�

Are there any exceptions to the new curriculum mandate?

So far, only , a K-8 gifted and talented program. However, some other school communities .

Randi Weingarten, head of the American Federation of Teachers, .

How do I know if the new curriculum is working for my child?

Schools are expected to screen students three times a year to assess their reading skills. Caregivers can find the results of those assessments in their , which indicate or needs more support to be performing at grade level. (These screeners are supposed to replace that assigned students a reading level from A-Z.)

Multiple experts said teachers are generally also doing more regular assessments on top of that, so it鈥檚 a good idea to get in touch with them if you have any concerns.

鈥淭he answer is: ask the teachers,鈥� said Susan Neuman, a literacy expert at New York University. They should have a sense of whether a student needs extra help based on a range of assessments beyond the screeners, she added.

What should I do if I鈥檓 concerned about my child鈥檚 progress?

Experts said caregivers should reach out to their child鈥檚 school if they suspect their child is behind in reading or if their screener results suggest they are below grade level.

鈥淎 plan needs to be put in place, so parents do need to serve as their child鈥檚 advocate,鈥� said Katie Pace Miles, a literacy expert at Brooklyn College who . 鈥淚 would ask about what skills can be reinforced at home, and what materials can be provided to the caregivers.鈥�

She said parents should ask their schools to outline whether they are offering their child extra small-group or one-on-one instruction, how many days a week it鈥檚 offered, and how long each session is.

鈥淧arents should not be left in the dark,鈥� Miles said. If a student continues to struggle despite efforts to provide extra help, caregivers may want to ask for more detailed assessments of their child and potentially request a special education evaluation, she said.

This was originally published by Chalkbeat. Sign up for their newsletters at . Chalkbeat is a nonprofit news site covering educational change in public schools.

Did you use this article in your work?

We鈥檇 love to hear how 社区黑料鈥檚 reporting is helping educators, researchers, and policymakers.