社区黑料

Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for 社区黑料 Newsletter

New York City education officials are hitting pause on releasing comprehensive artificial intelligence guidelines after their draft policy from March sparked .

Officials initially said their final guidance would be released in June, but backed away from that timeline during a Wednesday City Council hearing focused on AI in schools. Instead, the policy guidance will be released sometime this summer, First Deputy Chancellor Danielle Giunta said.

Giunta said the 鈥渟hifting national conversation, which has really escalated over just the last couple of weeks alone鈥� was one reason for the delay, along with nearly 6,500 comments responding to the March draft. Officials have not released those responses but told City Council members they would do so.

Worries about AI 鈥� and education technology in schools more broadly 鈥� have increased in recent months. More than half of City Council members urging Mayor Zohran Mamdani and schools Chancellor Kamar Samuels to pause AI use in schools citing concerns about learning and mental health. A broader petition seeking a moratorium on generative AI use in city schools has received .

The Education Department鈥檚 draft policy used a that spelled out various uses of AI and their risk levels. Assessments and grading are not allowed, for instance, but brainstorming lesson plans gets a green light. Student AI use was largely left out, even though it鈥檚 one of the most pressing issues schools face. In response to the draft policy, parents and largely criticized the approach.

Samuels, who did not attend Wednesday鈥檚 hearing, that the Education Department鈥檚 draft policy 鈥渕issed the mark鈥� that AI 鈥渋s the most invasive technology that we鈥檝e seen.鈥� He suggested the final guidance would have stricter limits for the city鈥檚 youngest students.

Giunta said Wednesday that the city is considering different expectations based on age and grade level and thinking about how to prepare older students 鈥渇or a world in which AI is already present without allowing AI to replace their own thinking.鈥�

City Council members repeatedly pressed Education Department officials about the extent to which AI tools are already used in classrooms and indicated families should have a greater say over how their children are exposed to it.

鈥淭here are huge gaps in our understanding of how the technology is being deployed and when,鈥� said Manhattan council member Carmen De La Rosa, who chairs the technology committee. 鈥淲e do need the time to be able to wrap our arms around what is happening in our classrooms.鈥�

Education officials said they are working with superintendents and principals to develop a more comprehensive sense of what tools schools are already using.

The Education Department鈥檚 stance on AI has whipsawed in recent years. When ChatGPT gained widespread use, city officials . Three months later, they rescinded the ban.

Former schools Chancellor David Banks , saying 鈥淎I can revolutionize how we function as a school system鈥� and could be used for everything from college advising to assessing student work. But he never released a clear policy, leaving that task to Mamdani and Samuels to complete. Meanwhile, schools have been left to .

Chalkbeat is a nonprofit news site covering educational change in public schools. This story was originally published by Chalkbeat. Sign up for their newsletters at .

Did you use this article in your work?

We鈥檇 love to hear how 社区黑料鈥檚 reporting is helping educators, researchers, and policymakers.